Is Psychotherapy a Spiritual Endeavor?

United States · CPD points & talks · Psychologists

Psychology as a discipline has in many instances eschewed notions of the spiritual, situating itself in the hallways of secular science and academia. This tendency harks back to the early days in the late 1800’s, when psychology was first established as an independent scientific discipline, and sought to claim its place as a science, equivalent in empirical rigour to other branches of scientific endeavour. This attempt to prove itself a legitimate scientific field of study lead in extreme form to projects such as radical behaviourism, which denied the relevance of the mind as a subject of enquiry. Reflecting on this from a contemporary perspective, one is struck by the absurdity of this proposition: psychology as a field of study which excludes the mind as a subject of interest? It wasn’t long before early cognitive and humanistic psychologists pointed out the obvious: that human beings could not be fully understood by studying only their external behaviour; that psychology needed to embark on a study of consciousness and subjectivity, which would distinguish it from other branches of science; and that ultimately, psychology should take its place as a human science, rather than strictly a natural science.

At the same time as he explored the mystery of the unconscious and its symbolic expression in dreams, Freud also endeavoured to establish psychoanalysis as a science, and to gain acceptance within the scientific community. Freud distanced himself from the ideas of Carl Jung, partly because he feared that Jung’s supernatural and spiritual foci would cast doubt on the credibility of psychoanalysis. Jung’s theories involve looking at psychotherapy through a spiritual lens, as the individual is seen to move towards individuation and fullness of being by integrating different elements into the self. The aspect of the self to be grappled with, which may be an archetypal element from the collective unconscious, comes to the individual through dreams and synchronous occurrences. In contrast, Freud attempted to ground his theory in the idea of biological drives, and the struggle between mankind’s primitive nature, and the surrounding culture.

Humanistic psychology also played with notions of the “self”, with Carl Rogers writing about the self-concept, and proposing ideas of genuineness and congruence with the true inner self and that which is presented to the world. However, Rogers stopped short of referring to the “soul”, and humanistic psychology largely remained a secular theory. Ideas of self-actualisation, human potential and the ‘fully functioning person’ do seem to border on conceptualising the human being as driven by higher motives, and these ideas lent themselves to development by some humanistic psychologists into a new approach, transpersonal psychology. Transpersonal psychology proposes that human beings are fundamentally spiritual beings, and opens the door to integration of psychology and psychotherapy with ancient and indigenous spiritual practices. While bookstore chains may feature shelves of literature on spiritual approaches to the psyche, transpersonal psychology remains largely outside of the mainstream academic discipline of psychology, most likely to be glossed over briefly in an introductory undergraduate course, but not a significant part of clinical training.

It seems to me that each individual practitioner faces the question of whether spirituality plays any role in their work. As a practitioner influenced by psychoanalytic theory and thinking, I am aware that Freud maintained scepticism towards ideas of religion and spirituality. Many psychoanalytic theorists might see spiritual and religious ideas as defence mechanisms; ways of denying mortality, human frailty or smallness, or easy explanations for human suffering, loss, and trauma. Religious and spiritual ideas have been seen as a delusion, in which humankind takes refuge against the unbearable blights of life on this earth. As Freud thought that an aspect of the therapist’s role is to promote patients’ functioning according to the reality principle, some psychoanalytic practitioners might follow suit, endeavouring to help patients face reality as it is, unaided by delusion. Where defences are left intact, this would be a concession to human frailty, not necessarily an acknowledgment of the sanguine nature of the patient’s spiritual or religious beliefs. While this might have been the approach in secular Vienna, many contemporary psychoanalytic practitioners working in the postmodern era might view patients’ religious and spiritual beliefs as important and valued components of the patient’s identity.

To return to the original question, though: is psychotherapy a spiritual endeavour? Again, I believe each individual practitioner thinks about this question in accordance with his or her worldview and therapeutic approach. In my view, spiritual practices and beliefs are not overtly part of the therapeutic process, as my understanding of my patient is constructed using the tools of our discipline, including empathy and curiosity about and exploration of unconscious dynamics.

However, I am going to go out on a limb and say that I see psychotherapy as spiritual work. A patient arrives for therapy, possibly with a clear presenting complaint. So often, the presenting complaint is the patient’s passport into psychotherapy, the real reasons being pre- or unconscious and inchoate: on some level, the patient is brought by his or her vague awareness of a process to be undertaken, which will involve becoming more fully him or her self – to borrow Jung’s term, a process of individuation which will involve confronting and shedding old, unhelpful defensive behaviours that once served the patient, but now constrain him or her from living fully. Robert Caper’s psychoanalytic text, A Mind of One’s Own, considers the view that optimal psychological development involves becoming fully one’s self, distinct from one’s objects. It appears that psychoanalysis has evolved from original ideas about neurosis and ordinary human misery, to a practice which holds the integrated, individuated self as a core value.

Freud offered us the concept of resistance, which is of key importance in understanding how the patient’s defence mechanisms may be mobilised against the therapeutic work and in the service of not facing what needs to be faced. Sometimes, a patient is open to working with and thinking about his or her resistances, venturing with courage into his or her internal world. I am struck by the watershed moments in therapy that can emerge from an accurate understanding of a dream or a poignant interpretation. I think many psychotherapists are aware of the magic of the psychotherapy process, and impressed by the way in which the unconscious elegantly expresses itself in dreams and other symbolic forms, and in the case of children, in play. Part of the mystery is how unconscious themes unveil themselves at the moment of therapeutic readiness, having lurked in the shadows imperceptibly until then.

Psychotherapy is meaningful work; it is an investment in a human life and an acknowledgment of its value; it is not a materialist or reductionist process, but rather a process which honours the person as a holistic and unique individual. If spirituality is about a concern with the inner life of an individual, and a belief that an inner path exists through which an individual can be lead to greater self-discovery, then I believe psychotherapy to be a spiritual endeavour.

Calabash · South Africa
Calabash Articles · South Africa
Calabash Partners · South Africa
Calabash Contributors · South Africa
Calabash Speakers · South Africa
Calabash Talks · South Africa
Calabash Sign up · South Africa
Calabash Sign in · South Africa
Allied Health Professionals CPD talks · South Africa
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy CPD talks · South Africa
Psychodynamic Therapy CPD talks · South Africa
Article · The core of 12 Step meetings – an insider’s view on why they are so effective · South Africa
Article · Facebook Ads for Health Care Professionals · South Africa
Article · Common Medications for Mood Stabilization · South Africa
CPD talks · South Africa
CPD talks · South Africa
Anxiety CPD talks · South Africa
Talk · Supporting People through Grief, Loss & Bereavement · South Africa
Talk · Sleep Difficulties in Babies and Toddlers · South Africa
Talk · Emotionally dysregulated clients: Supporting Families - 3. Window of tolerance · South Africa
How It Works · South Africa
Uploading an Article · South Africa
Frequently Asked Questions · South Africa
Calabash · Australia
Calabash Articles · Australia
Calabash Partners · Australia
Calabash Contributors · Australia
Calabash Speakers · Australia
Calabash Talks · Australia
Calabash Sign up · Australia
Calabash Sign in · Australia
Australian Counselling Association CPD talks · Australia
Dialectical Behavioural Therapy CPD talks · Australia
Mood Disorders CPD talks · Australia
Article · Reveries: Reflections on Psychoanalytic Work · Australia
Article · COVID-19 and Anxiety · Australia
Article · SAPC Dialogues: Sue Hawkridge · Australia
ADHD CPD talks · Australia
Dyspraxia CPD talks · Australia
Neonatal therapy CPD talks · Australia
Talk · Consent in Schools · Australia
Talk · Principles of Child-Centred Play Therapy & The Intake Session · Australia
Talk · Sexuality: Thoughts on perversions & sexual dysfunctions · Australia
Frequently Asked Questions · Australia
About Partners · Australia
About Calabash · Australia
Calabash · New Zealand
Calabash Articles · New Zealand
Calabash Partners · New Zealand
Calabash Contributors · New Zealand
Calabash Speakers · New Zealand
Calabash Talks · New Zealand
Calabash Sign up · New Zealand
Calabash Sign in · New Zealand
Psychodynamic Therapy CPD talks · New Zealand
Neurodiversity CPD talks · New Zealand
Australian Counselling Association CPD talks · New Zealand
Article · Intuitive Eating & Digestive Health · New Zealand
Article · How to Hold Sessions with Social Distancing · New Zealand
Article · A bit about PROMPT · New Zealand
OCD CPD talks · New Zealand
Gender Based Violence CPD talks · New Zealand
Religion CPD talks · New Zealand
Talk · South African Psychologists Moving to The UK: Everything you need to know to get started · New Zealand
Talk · Building Brains: Interpreting CT and MRI scan results & paper cases · New Zealand
Talk · Sleep Difficulties in Babies and Toddlers · New Zealand
Frequently Asked Questions · New Zealand
Uploading an Article · New Zealand
Uploading a Talk · New Zealand
Calabash · United Kingdom
Calabash Articles · United Kingdom
Calabash Partners · United Kingdom
Calabash Contributors · United Kingdom
Calabash Speakers · United Kingdom
Calabash Talks · United Kingdom
Calabash Sign up · United Kingdom
Calabash Sign in · United Kingdom
Australian Counselling Association CPD talks · United Kingdom
Neuro CPD talks · United Kingdom
Personality CPD talks · United Kingdom
Article · Medication for Anxiety · United Kingdom
Article · Note Taking in a Hospital Setting · United Kingdom
Article · Insights into Adlerian Theory and Therapy · United Kingdom
Communication CPD talks · United Kingdom
Stress CPD talks · United Kingdom
School Readiness CPD talks · United Kingdom
Talk · Understanding and Managing Central Auditory Processing Disorder · United Kingdom
Talk · Emotionally dysregulated clients: Supporting Families - 2. Accepting feelings & changing behaviour · United Kingdom
Talk · Perspectives on the Oedipus Complex: Freud, Klein & Lacan · United Kingdom
About Calabash · United Kingdom
How It Works · United Kingdom
Uploading a Talk · United Kingdom
Calabash · United States
Calabash Articles · United States
Calabash Partners · United States
Calabash Contributors · United States
Calabash Speakers · United States
Calabash Talks · United States
Calabash Sign up · United States
Calabash Sign in · United States
Personality CPD talks · United States
Couples CPD talks · United States
Dialectical Behavioural Therapy CPD talks · United States
Article · Schema Therapy · United States
Article · The Development of Masculinity in Ulwaluko kwa Xhosa · United States
Article · How my therapist missed my diagnosis: a patient’s experience of PND · United States
Hospital setting CPD talks · United States
Animal Assisted Therapy CPD talks · United States
Motor learning CPD talks · United States
Talk · Building Brains: Interpreting CT and MRI scan results & paper cases · United States
Talk · Understanding and Managing Central Auditory Processing Disorder · United States
Talk · Addressing Structural Racism · United States
Uploading an Article · United States
Uploading a Talk · United States
How It Works · United States
Calabash · Canada
Calabash Articles · Canada
Calabash Partners · Canada
Calabash Contributors · Canada
Calabash Speakers · Canada
Calabash Talks · Canada
Calabash Sign up · Canada
Calabash Sign in · Canada
Australian Counselling Association CPD talks · Canada
Neurodiversity CPD talks · Canada
Neuro CPD talks · Canada
Article · The Recovery Bus: A warning about addiction · Canada
Article · Understanding sensory processing disorder · Canada
Article · An Intro to Marketing for Healthcare Professionals · Canada
Cleft CPD talks · Canada
Infants CPD talks · Canada
Marketing CPD talks · Canada
Talk · Tour of the Enneagram Triads · Canada
Talk · Sensory & Emotional Regulation 1: An introduction to sensory regulation · Canada
Talk · Working with Adolescents in Psychotherapy · Canada
Uploading an Article · Canada
About Partners · Canada
About Calabash · Canada
Psychologist in Sydney