How my therapist missed my diagnosis: a patient’s experience of PND

South Africa · CPD courses & CPD points · Health Professionals

It’s easy to miss the signs. I told myself that the listlessness and inability to focus on anything was just porridge brain. I passed off the debilitating inertia as first-trimester fatigue. The inexplicable, overwhelming rage was legitimate irritability caused by (alternately) preggy hormones and my annoying family. I convinced myself that nervousness and anxiety were completely normal effects of pregnancy. All pregnant women worry, right? Don’t we all worry about the baby, the future, the household products that are probably giving our entire family cancer, the starving homeless people at the traffic lights, being attacked and raped in the night by unknown assailants? I passed off the twisted, obtrusive thoughts as my simply being a perverted person and who should not have been allowed to become a mother. Not for a second did it occur to me that I could have been suffering from Peri-Natal Distress (PND).

I’d been seeing a counselling psychologist for a while, mostly about work-related stresses. I’d developed a good relationship with her and I trusted her judgement. Eventually (towards the end of my first trimester) I confided in her that I didn’t “feel myself lately”, but I had trouble verbalising the extent of it. My therapist responsibly completed a questionnaire to analyse my symptoms.

Difficult to diagnose

The trouble is that many of the signs of PND could easily be mistaken for “normal” symptoms of pregnancy. Mood-swings and tearfulness are common in pregnant women, often brought on even by healthy hormonal changes. Overwhelm in social and professional settings can be rationalised by this as well. Most pregnant women experience changes in their appetite and/or sleep patterns, and weight gain is obviously expected so excessive comfort eating or lassitude may be missed too. Many tired or queasy pregnant women don’t make time for personal grooming or hobbies. 

The most dangerous signs of all, however, are the ones that can’t always be seen from the outside: the anxiety, the dark thoughts, the suicidal ideation.

I told my therapist that I wasn’t keen on taking drugs, especially being pregnant. Because of this – and because she knew that in my previous pregnancies the worst of my symptoms had eased significantly as I cleared the first trimester – she suggested giving it a few more weeks before reassessing the situation. She responsibly took my preferences into account. But she missed the signs. Just a few weeks later, I was hospitalised to be psychiatrically treated for PND.

Denial and shame

If we hadn’t missed the signs, my condition may not have deteriorated so drastically. If we had intervened earlier, perhaps I would have been spared the months of drugs, panic attacks and voices in my head. But the truth was I knew this was different to my other pregnancies. As I wrote in my diary (later published as Through the Window: How I Beat PND):

I agreed with her that I should give it some more time. I told her that these were probably just the normal ups and downs of pregnancy. I didn’t tell her that the downs were much worse than I’d ever experienced in my life and were starting to terrify me. I didn’t tell her that I was petrified of being diagnosed with depression because I don’t want there to be something ‘wrong’ with me. That I’m terrified that the world will judge me. That I will judge myself.

A diagnosis feels like such a formal, ongoing undertaking. Depression is a big deal. And it makes my ‘problem’ seem like a big deal. And that’s scary.

I loved and respected my therapist, and I still do. I do not blame her for missing the signs, because I missed them too. If I’m brutally honest with myself, I hid their severity from her. I misled her – and myself.

Professionals need to be aware of this and look deeper into a patient’s responses before excluding the possibility of PND. Anyone who works with pregnant women or news mothers should be on the look-out for possible cases of PND. That means not just psychologists and psychiatrists, but also gynaecologists, obstetricians, paediatricians, GPs, nurses, pharmacists, clinic sisters and social workers. Take every single possible sign very seriously.

Understanding what it’s like

The best way to truly understand another person is to empathise with them, and this cannot be done if you do not know what they have been through. This is why I wrote Through the Window: How I Beat PND – to give readers a look into what it is like to live with and through PND.

The book is endorsed by the South African Depression and Anxiety Group (SADAG) and features a foreword and afterword by Cape Town psychiatrist and mother Bavi Vythilingum, as well as footnotes and resources to help the reader to identify symptoms and treatment options.

Through the Window: How I Beat PND is available at www.laurenshapiro.co.za/books

Calabash · South Africa
Calabash Articles · South Africa
Calabash Partners · South Africa
Calabash Contributors · South Africa
Calabash Speakers · South Africa
Calabash Talks · South Africa
Calabash Sign up · South Africa
Calabash Sign in · South Africa
Therapy Modalities CPD courses & CPD points · South Africa
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy CPD courses & CPD points · South Africa
Children, teens & families CPD courses & CPD points · South Africa
Article · Why Would a Baby Need a Psychiatrist · South Africa
Article · Medications for ADHD · South Africa
Article · On Santa Claus and Other Childhood Mysteries · South Africa
CPD courses & CPD points · South Africa
Group therapy CPD courses & CPD points · South Africa
Executive functions CPD courses & CPD points · South Africa
Talk · Dyslexia: Conceptual framework and therapeutic interventions · South Africa
Talk · Combined Child-Parent Model of Assessment & Therapeutic Communication · South Africa
Talk · Thoughts on Infantile Trauma and Psychoanalytic Intervention · South Africa
About Calabash · South Africa
Uploading a Talk · South Africa
Frequently Asked Questions · South Africa
Calabash · Australia
Calabash Articles · Australia
Calabash Partners · Australia
Calabash Contributors · Australia
Calabash Speakers · Australia
Calabash Talks · Australia
Calabash Sign up · Australia
Calabash Sign in · Australia
Therapy Modalities CPD courses & CPD points · Australia
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy CPD courses & CPD points · Australia
Couples CPD courses & CPD points · Australia
Article · How my therapist missed my diagnosis: a patient’s experience of PND · Australia
Article · SAPC Dialogues: Sue Hawkridge · Australia
Article · Cindy Strydom on Establishing a new practice · Australia
CPD courses & CPD points · Australia
Personality CPD courses & CPD points · Australia
Recovery CPD courses & CPD points · Australia
Talk · Language Discordance and the Associated Ethical Dilemmas · Australia
Talk · Current Trends in Childhood Psychiatric Diagnosis · Australia
Talk · Understanding Dyslexia: The Speech-Language Pathologist's role · Australia
About Calabash · Australia
Uploading an Article · Australia
About Partners · Australia
Calabash · New Zealand
Calabash Articles · New Zealand
Calabash Partners · New Zealand
Calabash Contributors · New Zealand
Calabash Speakers · New Zealand
Calabash Talks · New Zealand
Calabash Sign up · New Zealand
Calabash Sign in · New Zealand
Imago Relationship Therapy CPD courses & CPD points · New Zealand
Children, teens & families CPD courses & CPD points · New Zealand
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy CPD courses & CPD points · New Zealand
Article · Parenting in Cyberspace · New Zealand
Article · SAPC Dialogues: Introduction to the Dialogues · New Zealand
Article · Napping in Young Children · New Zealand
COVID-19 CPD courses & CPD points · New Zealand
Human Rights CPD courses & CPD points · New Zealand
Trauma CPD courses & CPD points · New Zealand
Talk · The Origins of Mentalising & Implications for Attachment, Personality & Psychotherapy - Part 2 · New Zealand
Talk · Codependency: Identifying & addressing an underlying, untreated addiction in our clients · New Zealand
Talk · The Enneagram: A Jungian Perspective on Persona & Shadow Aspects · New Zealand
Terms of Use · New Zealand
Uploading an Article · New Zealand
Frequently Asked Questions · New Zealand
Calabash · United Kingdom
Calabash Articles · United Kingdom
Calabash Partners · United Kingdom
Calabash Contributors · United Kingdom
Calabash Speakers · United Kingdom
Calabash Talks · United Kingdom
Calabash Sign up · United Kingdom
Calabash Sign in · United Kingdom
Other allied CPD courses & CPD points · United Kingdom
Australian Counselling Association CPD courses & CPD points · United Kingdom
Neurodiversity CPD courses & CPD points · United Kingdom
Article · Managing Parent Counselling · United Kingdom
Article · How to Hold Sessions with Social Distancing · United Kingdom
Article · SAPC Dialogues: Sue Hawkridge · United Kingdom
Therapy CPD courses & CPD points · United Kingdom
COVID-19 CPD courses & CPD points · United Kingdom
CPD courses & CPD points · United Kingdom
Talk · Developing a Listening Brain: An introduction to Auditory-Verbal Therapy · United Kingdom
Talk · Group psychology: Psychoanalytic & sociological considerations · United Kingdom
Talk · HPCSA Guidelines on the use of Social Media · United Kingdom
Uploading an Article · United Kingdom
Privacy Policy · United Kingdom
Uploading a Talk · United Kingdom
Calabash · United States
Calabash Articles · United States
Calabash Partners · United States
Calabash Contributors · United States
Calabash Speakers · United States
Calabash Talks · United States
Calabash Sign up · United States
Calabash Sign in · United States
Australian Counselling Association CPD courses & CPD points · United States
Other allied CPD courses & CPD points · United States
Clinical issues CPD courses & CPD points · United States
Article · Insights into Adlerian Theory and Therapy · United States
Article · SAPC Dialogues: Challenges and Innovations · United States
Article · Schema Therapy · United States
Divorce CPD courses & CPD points · United States
Sensory System CPD courses & CPD points · United States
School Readiness CPD courses & CPD points · United States
Talk · Insomnia: Causes, features & management · United States
Talk · New ways of Approaching Borderline Personality Disorder: Insights on Trauma & Addiction · United States
Talk · Neuropsychological Syndromes · United States
About Contributors · United States
Terms of Use · United States
About Calabash · United States
Calabash · Canada
Calabash Articles · Canada
Calabash Partners · Canada
Calabash Contributors · Canada
Calabash Speakers · Canada
Calabash Talks · Canada
Calabash Sign up · Canada
Calabash Sign in · Canada
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy CPD courses & CPD points · Canada
Children, teens & families CPD courses & CPD points · Canada
Personality CPD courses & CPD points · Canada
Article · CBT: Band-Aid Solution or Sufferer's Balm? · Canada
Article · Apps, Language & Learning: What you need to know · Canada
Article · Tidbits on Treating the Dizzy Patient · Canada
CPD courses & CPD points · Canada
Apraxia CPD courses & CPD points · Canada
Communication CPD courses & CPD points · Canada
Talk · Sexuality: Thoughts on Perversions and Sexual Dysfunctions · Canada
Talk · The Origins of Mentalising & Implications for Attachment, Personality & Psychotherapy - Part 2 · Canada
Talk · HPCSA Guidelines on the Keeping of Patient Records · Canada
About Contributors · Canada
Uploading a Talk · Canada
About Calabash · Canada
Psychologist in Sydney